The claim was brought in negligence and for breach of statutory duty. In negligence, the court applied the general duty of care owed by an occupier of land, following the High Court of Australia's approach in Australian Safeway Stores v Zaluzna (1987) and Hackshaw v Shaw (1984), under which describing the injured person as a trespasser does not by itself determine whether a duty is owed. Breach was assessed under the test in Wyong Shire Council v Shirt (1980): a risk is foreseeable if it is not far-fetched or fanciful, even if it is unlikely, and the court must then weigh the magnitude and probability of the risk against the expense, difficulty and inconvenience of precautions.
The statutory claim relied on section 41 of the Mines Inspection Act 1968 (Tas), which requires that an excavation in or about a mine that ceases to be used for mining operations be kept safely and securely fenced, covered over or filled in, where it is likely to be dangerous otherwise. The court held that a quarry is a "mine" within the meaning of the Act, that section 41 applies to excavations abandoned before the Act came into force, and that its breach gives rise to a civil action for damages.
Contributory negligence of a child is assessed by the standard reasonably expected of a child of similar age, intelligence and experience (McHale v Watson (1966)).
On 1 December 1979, at about 9 am, the plaintiff, then aged 11, and a friend went to a disused quarry next to the Flagstaff Gully Road reservoir near Hobart, Tasmania. The quarry had supplied stone fill for the reservoir in the early 1960s and had since been neither raked nor benched. Its uneven face, about 20 metres high at its highest point, sloped at between 39 and 79 degrees.
The boys decided to climb the face, each trying to reach the top first. Near the top the plaintiff pulled himself up on a large rock, which gave way. He fell back to the quarry floor, and the rock landed on his left hand, causing a severe crush and degloving injury. His friend found him unconscious and carried him home.
The Clarence Municipality owned and occupied the land; the quarrying itself had been carried out by the Metropolitan Water Board. The quarry was not fenced around its rim or across its entrance and had no warning signs. The council used it to store disused equipment, which made it attractive to the plaintiff as an adventure playground. He visited it frequently and had built cubby houses there, although he had never before climbed the face. There was no evidence that other children used the quarry or that council officers knew or ought to have known that he did. Access was easy, in particular under a reservoir fence whose wire apron had become displaced; the plaintiff and the guests at his birthday party had used this route the day before the accident. His mother had warned him on many occasions not to go to the quarry.
The plaintiff sued the council through his mother in September 1982. The case came to trial nearly thirteen years after the accident.
The plaintiff argued that the council had failed to prevent access to the site, particularly by children, to inspect and maintain the fencing and the quarry face, to remove loose rock and to display warning signs. He further argued that the quarry was an excavation in a mine within section 41 of the Mines Inspection Act 1968, which the council had failed to keep safely and securely fenced, covered over or filled in, or to mark with a sufficient warning.
The council denied that it owed the plaintiff any duty of care, whether under the classic rules for trespassers or under the more general duty recognised in Australian law. It argued that the quarry was effectively fenced against all but the most determined intruders and relied on expert evidence that the section of the face the plaintiff had climbed was "not too bad". It contended that section 41 did not apply, because the quarry had been abandoned before the Act came into force, applying it would create a retrospective liability, and the previous legislation had treated quarries and mines separately. It also alleged contributory negligence: the plaintiff had entered the site knowing he was forbidden to do so and had climbed a face he knew or should have known to be dangerous.
The court rejected the council's reliance on the plaintiff's status as a trespasser and asked what dangers an occupier should have anticipated from the state in which the quarry was left. The judge noted that comparable disused quarries in the Hobart area had nearly vertical faces, which no reasonable person, even a child, could be expected to attempt without climbing equipment. After inspecting the site twice, however, he found that the photographs understated the steepness of the face, and that near its centre there was a less steep, more solid section with an obvious dog-leg line to the top, which an active 11-year-old could readily attempt without appreciating the loose rock higher up. A reasonably careful council officer should therefore have foreseen that the face would present an attractive climbing challenge to adventurous children. Although such climbing was not very likely in this comparatively remote location, the risk was not far-fetched or fanciful.
Weighing the risk against the cost of precautions, the court relied on a mining engineer's estimate that the face could have been stabilised for about AUD 25,000 to 30,000 or the quarry securely fenced for about AUD 15,000 to 20,000, and did not consider these costs unreasonable for a municipal council, particularly as it had fenced the adjacent reservoir. The quarry had been abandoned without any steps to reduce the danger, and the council was in breach of its duty of care to a class of persons, namely children, which included the plaintiff.
On the statutory claim, the court held that section 41 applied to the quarry even though it had been abandoned before the Act came into force. The quarry was likely to be dangerous unless securely fenced, it was not so fenced, and the absence of secure fencing was causative, since without it the plaintiff may well not have entered the site. The court did not read the duty to "cover over" as requiring the face to be raked and benched, and considered filling in the quarry impracticable.
The plaintiff's damages were reduced by one third for contributory negligence. Although children unaware that their conduct is forbidden or dangerous will not normally be found contributorily negligent, the plaintiff was an intelligent 11-year-old who had been repeatedly warned by his mother, and he should have appreciated that climbing the face, apparently in competition with his friend, carried a substantial risk.
The case is noteworthy because the hazard was a man-made, abandoned rock face: a disused quarry that nobody had secured after operations ended. The court found the council liable, as owner and occupier, on two independent bases: common-law negligence and breach of a statutory duty to keep abandoned mine excavations safely and securely fenced. The court did not rely on the plaintiff's status as a trespasser. It looked at the real condition of the site and asked whether children climbing the face was a foreseeable risk. It held that it was, because part of the face offered a climbable line attractive to active children, and because the owner could have secured the site at reasonable cost. Notably, there was no evidence that other children used the quarry or that the council knew of the plaintiff's visits; foreseeability of access by children was sufficient.
For mountaineering, the case concerns artificial hazards that look climbable, not natural crags. It does not mean that every cliff or crag must be fenced. The decisive factors were the abandonment of a man-made hazard, an inviting climbing line, the foreseeability of access by children and the low cost of precautions. The court itself drew the line: an occupier could not reasonably be expected to foresee unaided climbing of a near-vertical face. By analogy, the same reasoning may be relevant to outdoor artificial climbing walls and similar structures that are disused, unsupervised or left accessible. An owner who builds or keeps a structure that invites climbing, or who leaves a climbable structure behind, can reasonably be expected to prevent unsupervised access by children or to warn of the danger. This is an extension of the court's logic and not a holding of the case, and it would depend on the facts and the applicable law.
Comparison with other cases in the database shows that liability of landowners and of those who create hazards turns on similar considerations across legal systems. In ZA v Smith and Another, the South African Supreme Court of Appeal held the owners of a commercially operated nature reserve liable for failing to warn a paying adult visitor of a concealed danger near the edge of a gorge, a case concerning a natural hazard on land run as a business. In the German case OLG Karlsruhe 14 U 60/16, persons who installed a slackline in a public park were held liable for creating an unexpected hazard for other users. Stone differs from both: the land was neither commercially operated nor open to visitors, and the injured person was a child who had entered without permission. Liability nevertheless followed from the fact that the owner had left behind a man-made structure that invited climbing.
The judgment predates the civil liability legislation adopted in the Australian states in the early 2000s, including the Civil Liability Act 2002 (Tas), which limits liability for obvious risks and dangerous recreational activities. How these provisions would apply to a child in comparable circumstances today would need to be assessed separately.